Over the years I've
received scores of e-mail queries from people seeking answers to basic questions
about Buddhism. Here are my answers to some of the most common ones. These answers
reflect my own opinions and interpretations and in no way represent a "definitive"
Theravada Buddhist point of view. My hope is that these answers, along with the
accompanying links and references to suttas and other texts, will serve as useful
hints to help steer you in the direction of finding answers of your own.
If
you have a question you'd like to see answered here, please let me know.
Buddhist
doctrine and terminology
Is Buddhism a religion or a philosophy?
The
Buddha referred to his teachings simply as Dhamma-vinaya -- "the doctrine
and discipline" -- but for centuries people have tried to categorize the
teachings in various ways, trying to fit them into the prevailing molds of cultural,
philosophical, and religious thought. Buddhism is an ethical system -- a way of
life -- that leads to a very specific goal and that possesses some aspects of
both religion and philosophy:
It is a philosophy.
Like most philosophies,
Buddhism attempts to frame the complexities of human existence in a way that reassures
us that there is, in fact, some underlying order to the Universe. In the Four
Noble Truths the Buddha crisply summarizes our predicament: there is suffering,
it has a cause, it has an end, and there is a way to reach the end. The teachings
on kamma provide a thorough and logically self-consistent description of the nature
of cause-and-effect. And even the Buddhist view of cosmology, which some may at
first find farfetched, is a logical extension of the law of kamma. According to
the Dhamma, a deep and unshakable logic pervades the world.
It is not a philosophy.
Unlike most philosophical systems, which rely on speculation and the power
of reason to arrive at certain kinds of logical truths, Buddhism relies on the
direct observation of one's personal experience and on honing certain skills in
order to gain true understanding and wisdom. Idle speculation has no place in
Buddhist practice. Although studying in the classroom, reading books, and engaging
in spirited debate can play a vital part in developing a cognitive understanding
of basic Buddhist concepts, the heart of Buddhism can never be realized this way.
The Dhamma is not an abstract system of thought designed to delight the intellect;
it is a roadmap to be used, one whose essential purpose is to lead the practitioner
to the ultimate goal, nibbana.
It is a religion.
At the heart of each
of the world's great religions lies a transcendent ideal around which its doctrinal
principles orbit. In Buddhism this truth is nibbana, the hallmark of the cessation
of suffering and stress, a truth of utter transcendence that stands in singular
distinction from anything we might encounter in our ordinary sensory experience.
Nibbana is the sine qua non of Buddhism, the guiding star and ultimate goal towards
which all the Buddha's teachings point. Because it aims at such a lofty transcendent
ideal, we might fairly call Buddhism a religion.
It is not a religion.
In
stark contrast to the world's other major religions, however, Buddhism invokes
no divinity, no supreme Creator or supreme Self, no Holy Spirit or omniscient
loving God to whom we might appeal for salvation.[1] Instead, Buddhism calls for
us to hoist ourselves up by our own bootstraps: to develop the discernment we
need to distinguish between those qualities within us that are unwholesome and
those that are truly noble and good, and to learn how to nourish the good ones
and expunge the bad. This is the path to Buddhism's highest perfection, nibbana.
Not even the Buddha can take you to that goal; you alone must do the work necessary
to complete the journey:
"Therefore, Ananda, be islands unto yourselves,
refuges unto yourselves, seeking no external refuge; with the Dhamma as your island,
the Dhamma as your refuge, seeking no other refuge." [DN 16]
Despite
its non-theistic nature, however, Buddhist practice does call for a certain kind
of faith. It is not blind faith, an uncritical acceptance of the Buddha's word
as transmitted through scripture. Instead it is saddha, a confidence born of taking
refuge in the Triple Gem; it is a willingness to trust that the Dhamma, when practiced
diligently, will lead to the rewards promised by the Buddha. Saddha is a provisional
acceptance of the teachings, that is ever subject to critical evaluation during
the course of one's practice, and which must be balanced by one's growing powers
of discernment. For many Buddhists, this faith is expressed and reinforced through
traditional devotional practices, such as bowing before a Buddha statue and reciting
passages from the early Pali texts. Despite a superficial resemblance to the rites
of many theistic religions, however, these activities are neither prayers nor
pleas for salvation directed towards a transcendent Other. They are instead useful
and inspiring gestures of humility and respect for the profound nobility and worth
of the Triple Gem.
Note:
1. According to Buddhist cosmology, every living
being dwells in one of thirty-one distinct "planes", of which our familiar
human plane is but one. Some of these realms are home to beings (the devas) with
unusual powers and extraordinarily subtle and refined physical bodies -- or even
no body at all. Their god-like status is, however, short-lived; like all living
beings, they are mortal and ultimately subject to death and rebirth in other planes
according to the purity and skillfulness of their actions (kamma). One of these
devas, the Great Brahma, is so clouded by his own delusion that he believes himself
to be the all-powerful, all-seeing creator of the universe (see DN 11).
See
also:
" "The Dhamma: Is it a Philosophy?" in Buddhism in a
Nutshell, by Narada Thera
" "Is it a Religion?" in Buddhism
in a Nutshell, by Narada Thera
" "Two Faces of the Dhamma,"
by Bhikkhu Bodhi
" "The Five Spiritual Faculties," by Bhikkhu
Bodhi
" "Opening the Door to the Dhamma: Respect in Buddhist Thought
& Practice," by Thanissaro Bhikkhu.
" "The Road to Nirvana
is Paved with Skillful Intentions," by Thanissaro Bhikkhu.
Is
Vipassana the same as Theravada?
No.
The Pali word vipassana -- often
translated as "insight" -- has a variety of meanings. First, it refers
to the flash of liberating intuitive understanding that marks the culmination
of Buddhist meditation practice.[1] In the Pali discourses vipassana also refers
to the mind's ability to witness clearly as events unfold in the present moment.
In this sense it is a skill that a meditator develops using a broad arsenal of
meditative tools and techniques. With practice, this skill can bring the meditator
to the threshold of liberating insight.[2] In its third meaning, one that has
become especially popular in the West in recent years, "Vipassana" (usually
with a capital "V") refers to a system of meditation -- vipassana bhavana,
or "Insight Meditation" -- that is based on an interpretation of the
Satipatthana Sutta (MN 10), the Buddha's concise "how-to" guide to the
development of mindfulness (sati).[3]
Followers of the popular Vipassana movement
often cite the Satipatthana Sutta as the essence of the Buddha's teachings; some
even claim that the instructions it contains are the only ones necessary for achieving
liberating insight. Theravada Buddhism, by contrast, embraces the thousands of
discourses of the Pali Canon, each highlighting a different aspect of the Buddha's
teachings. In Theravada each discourse supports, depends upon, reflects, and informs
all the others; even a discourse as important as the Satipatthana Sutta is seen
as but a single thread in the Buddha's complex tapestry of teachings.
Although
many students do find all they want in Vipassana, some have a nagging sense that
something fundamental is missing. This reaction is hardly surprising, since the
Satipatthana discourse itself was delivered to a group of relatively advanced
students who were already quite experienced and well established in the path of
Dhamma practice. Happily, all those missing pieces can be found in the Pali Canon.
In the Canon we find the Buddha's teachings on generosity and virtue, the twin
pillars upon which all spiritual practice is built. His teachings on the recollection
of the Buddha, Dhamma, and Sangha serve to strengthen the development of saddha
(faith, confidence), which provides a potent fuel to sustain Dhamma practice long
after we return home from that meditation retreat. In the Canon we also find his
teachings on the drawbacks of sensuality and the value of renunciation; on developing
all the factors in the Eightfold Path, including those that are seldom explored
during organized Vipassana retreats: right speech, right livelihood, right effort,
and right concentration (meaning jhana). And there is much, much more.
In
Theravada, the path to liberating insight does not boil down to a single meditation
technique or to being continuously mindful. The path to Awakening is full of surprising
twists and turns but, thankfully, the Buddha left for us an assortment of tools
to use and skills to learn to help us safely make the journey.
See also: "What
is Theravada Buddhism?"
Notes:
1. Buddhist Dictionary: Manual of
Buddhist Terms and Doctrines by Nyanatiloka (Kandy: Buddhist Publication Society,
1988).
2. See "One Tool Among Many: The Place of Vipassana in Buddhist
Practice" (Thanissaro Bhikkhu)
3. The modern Vipassana movement grew
out of the tradition of Satipatthana Vipassana, a meditation system based on the
Satipatthana Sutta and developed by Burmese monks in the early 20th century. By
the 1950's the Burmese teachers Sayagyi U Ba Khin (a layman; 1899-1971) and Mahasi
Sayadaw (a monk; 1904-1982) had independently codified and institutionalized these
teachings, making them widely accessible across South Asia and, eventually, the
West. The Satipatthana Vipassana approach to meditation continues to enjoy widespread
popularity among laypeople in the West. See Satipatthana Vipassana: Insight Through
Mindfulness by Mahasi Sayadaw (Kandy: Buddhist Publication Society, 1990) and
The Essentials of Buddha Dhamma in Meditative Practice by U Ba Khin (Kandy: Buddhist
Publication Society, 1981).
If
we're all reborn when we die, how does Buddhism explain the world's increasing
population?
According to Buddhist cosmology, when a living being[1] passes
away he or she is reborn into one of thirty-one distinct "planes" or
"realms" of existence, of which the human realm is just one. An increase
in the human population simply implies that creatures from other planes are being
reborn into the human realm at a rate faster than humans are dying. Likewise,
a decline in the human population would imply that humans, upon death, are taking
rebirth in other planes (or exiting samsara altogether) at a rate faster than
other creatures are taking rebirth as humans. These sorts of population shifts
have been occurring for countless eons and in themselves hold little cosmic significance.
Note:
1. Except an arahant, a fully-enlightened being. Arahants have escaped
the round of rebirths once and for all and, upon death, are not reborn.
If
there's no self, then who gets enlightened?
If there's no self, then what
gets reborn?
If there's no self, then why...?
Nowhere in the Pali Canon
does Buddha categorically declare, without qualification, "There is no self".[1]
Any question that begins along the lines of, "If there's no self..."
is thus inherently misleading, dooming the questioner to a hopeless tangle of
confusion -- "a thicket of [wrong] views" [MN 2]. Such questions are
best put aside altogether in favor of more fruitful lines of questioning.[2]
Notes:
1. See "The Not-self Strategy" and "No-self or Not-self?"
by Thanissaro Bhikkhu
2. See "Questions of Skill" by Thanissaro
Bhikkhu
I hear the word "sangha"
used a lot these days in Buddhist circles. What does it really mean?
The Pali
word "sangha" literally means "group" or "congregation",
but when it is used in the suttas, the word usually refers to one of two very
specific kinds of groups: either the community of Buddhist monastics (bhikkhus
and bhikkhunis), or the community of people who have attained at least the first
stage of Awakening. In recent decades, a new usage of the word has emerged in
the West, one that seems to have no basis in classical Theravada Buddhist teachings:
the usage of the word "sangha" to describe a meditation group or any
sort of spiritual community.[1] It sounds innocent enough, but this particular
usage can -- and often does -- lead to profound confusion concerning one of the
most fundamental underpinnings of the Buddha's teachings, the going for refuge
in the Triple Gem.
The act of going for refuge in the Buddha, Dhamma, and
Sangha[2] marks a major turning point in one's spiritual development, the real
start of the journey down the Buddhist path.[3] It helps foster a healthy attitude
towards Buddhist practice by encouraging the development of right view, and serves
as a constant reminder both of the goal of practice and of the means to achieve
that goal. It is therefore crucial to be clear and precise about the meaning of
the refuges, lest we end up heading down a road quite different from the one the
Buddha had in mind.
In taking refuge in the Sangha, we set our inner sights
on the ideal community of Noble Ones (ariya-sangha) -- those monks, nuns, laywomen,
and laymen who, throughout history, have by their own diligent efforts successfully
carried out the Buddha's instructions and gained at least a glimpse of the supreme
happiness of nibbana. If this is the direction in which we also wish to go, then
it is to these individuals that we should turn for refuge:
The Sangha of the
Blessed One's disciples who have practiced well... who have practiced straight-forwardly...
who have practiced methodically... who have practiced masterfully -- in other
words, the four types [of noble disciples] when taken as pairs, the eight when
taken as individual types -- they are the Sangha of the Blessed One's disciples:
worthy of gifts, worthy of hospitality, worthy of offerings, worthy of respect,
the incomparable field of merit for the world.[AN XII.12]
But going for refuge
doesn't stop there. We are also asked to turn to the monastic community (bhikkhu-sangha)
for refuge, for it is thanks to the unbroken lineage of this 2,600-year-old institution
that we are fortunate enough today to be able to hear the teachings. Moreover,
the living example of the monastic community serves to remind us of the immense
value of generosity, of living a morally upright life, of renunciation -- in short,
it reminds us that it is indeed possible to live a life fully in tune with every
aspect of the Buddha's teachings. In reality, of course, not every monk or nun
necessarily lives up to the Buddha's high standards of conduct. For this reason
it is to the institution of the Sangha that we turn to refuge, not to the individual
members themselves. This is the Sangha to which lay people have turned since the
time of the Buddha:
I go to Master Gotama for refuge, to the Dhamma, and to
the Sangha of monks. May Master Gotama remember me as a lay follower who has gone
to him for refuge, from this day forward, for life. [DN 2, MN 72, SN LI.15, AN
IV.184, etc.]
So it is these exceptional groups of people -- the ariya-sangha
and the bhikkhu-sangha -- that define the Third Gem and Refuge; it is to these
groups that we are asked to turn for refuge, not to some vaguely defined community
of like-minded Dhamma friends and fellow meditators. In which group would you
rather put your trust?
In an effort to resolve this confusion, some writers
have proposed various alternatives to the word "sangha" to describe
gatherings and communities of Dhamma companions.[4] But this still leaves me wondering
why we must invoke the Pali language here at all. Does a meditation group really
need a special name? Why not simply call it a "meditation group" and
leave it at that?
"Sangha" is an important term with a rich and
precise meaning. It stands for something truly extraordinary and brilliant that
can constantly remind us of the highest and most excellent possibilities the Path
has to offer. Let's use it well.
Notes:
1. The Buddhist Religion: A Historical
Introduction (fourth edition) by R.H. Robinson & W.L. Johnson (Belmont, California:
Wadsworth, 1997), p. 307.
2. Here I follow the convention of capitalizing
"Sangha" when referring to the third object of refuge. [Go back to text]
3. See Refuge: An Introduction to the Buddha, Dhamma and Sangha by Thanissaro
Bhikkhu (1997).
4. Two such proposals are parisa (the "fourfold assembly":
monks (bhikkhus), nuns (bhikkhunis), male lay followers (upasakas), and female
lay followers (upasikas), regardless of spiritual attainment; see Refuge: An Introduction
to the Buddha, Dhamma and Sangha by Thanissaro Bhikkhu (1997)) and gana (chapter;
quorum; gang).
Who is Maitreya
(Metteyya)?
Have there been other Buddhas?
What's the difference between
a Buddha and an arahant?
What's a "Private Buddha" (paccekabuddha)?
According to Theravada tradition, many Buddhas have come and gone over countless
eons. Every once in a great while, after a long period of spiritual darkness blankets
the world, an individual is eventually born who, through his own efforts, rediscovers
the long-forgotten path to Awakening and liberates himself once and for all from
the long round of rebirth, thereby becoming an arahant ("worthy one",
one who has fully realized Awakening). If such a being chooses not to share his
discovery with others he is called a "Silent" or "Private"
Buddha (paccekabuddha). If he chooses to deliver his message (sasana)to the world
he is called, simply, a Buddha. Some of a Buddha's followers may themselves become
arahants, but they are not Buddhas, since they relied on a Buddha to show them
the way to Awakening. (All Buddhas and paccekabuddhas are arahants, but not all
arahants are Buddhas or paccekabuddhas.) No matter how far and wide the sasana
spreads, sooner or later it succumbs to the inexorable law of anicca (impermanence),
and fades from memory. The world descends again into darkness, and the eons-long
cycle repeats.
The most recent Buddha was born Siddhattha Gotama in India
in the sixth century BCE. He is the one we usually mean when we refer to "The
Buddha".[1]
The next Buddha due to appear is said to be Maitreya (Skt;
Pali: Metteyya), a bodhisatta currently residing in the Tusita heavens. Legend
has it that at some time in the far distant future, once the teachings of the
current Buddha have long been forgotten, he will be reborn as a human being, rediscover
the Four Noble Truths, and teach the Noble Eightfold Path once again. Although
he plays an important role in some Mahayana Buddhist traditions, whose followers
appeal to him for favorable rebirth and salvation,[2] he plays an insignificant
role in Theravada. I believe he's mentioned only once in the entire Tipitaka,
in the Cakkavatti-Sihanada Sutta (DN 26; The Lion's Roar on the Turning of the
Wheel):
[The Buddha:] And in that time of the people with an eighty-thousand-year
life-span, there will arise in the world a Blessed Lord, an Arahant fully enlightened
Buddha named Metteyya, endowed with wisdom and conduct, a Well-farer, Knower of
the worlds, incomparable Trainer of men to be tamed, Teacher of gods and humans,
enlightened and blessed, just as I am now. -- "The Long Discourses of the
Buddha" (formerly "Thus Have I Heard"), Maurice Walshe, trans.
(Boston: Wisdom Publications, 1987), p 403f.
In Chinese and Japanese art,
that jolly fellow with the large belly represents Maitreya from a previous lifetime.
[3]
Notes:
1. DN 14 and DN 32 mention six previous Buddhas: Vipassi, Sikhi,
Vessabhu, Kakusandha, Konagamana, and Kassapa. MN 116 includes a long list of
past paccekabuddhas.
2. The Buddhist Religion: A Historical Introduction (fourth
edition) by R.H. Robinson & W.L. Johnson (Belmont, California: Wadsworth,
1997), pp. 105-6.
3. Ibid., p. 106.
Practical Buddhism
How can I find other people with whom to study Dhamma and practice
meditation?
" Ask around.
" Browse through the listings of Dhamma
centers and meditation groups that are published in magazines and websites (see
"Learning and Practicing Meditation" in the "Other Theravada Sources"
page.)
" Explore your local universities or community colleges. Do they
have any Buddhist groups or clubs? Visit the student lounges, cafeterias, libraries,
campus bookstore, etc. -- anywhere you might find bulletin boards with announcements
of campus events.
" Look for flyers posted at local bookstores, natural
food stores, "New Age"-type shops, etc.
" Start a meditation
group or Dhamma study group in your own living room. Advertise it with a flyer
posted at one of the places mentioned above (ask for permission first!). You may
be the only one attending for awhile, but be patient.
" Check the telephone
book (Yellow Pages), and look under "Churches" (Thai temples? Vietnamese
temples?) or "Meditation". Even if you don't see exactly what you're
looking for, you may at least be able to contact someone who can give you some
ideas of whom to call. Someone at a Hindu ashram or a Benedictine monastery may
have some suggestions.
" More and more hospitals and health clinics offer
stress-reduction and pain-control programs that make use of simplified meditation
techniques borrowed from Buddhist traditions. The person in charge of one of these
programs may know of ongoing Buddhist meditation groups or Dhamma centers in your
area.
" Write to someone at a monastery or Dhamma center in a neighboring
city, state, province, etc. and ask for his or her suggestions.
" Ask
around.
There are no meditation
centers or other Dhamma students nearby. How should I study Dhamma on my own?
Are you sure there aren't any meditation groups or centers nearby? Even in
areas dominated by other religious traditions there may be a few other people
quietly and inconspicuously practicing Dhamma by themselves. With a little patient
detective work you may be able to find them (see "How can I find other people
with whom to study Dhamma and practice meditation?", above).
But if you
really are alone, don't despair. Although having a supportive community of like-minded
Dhamma friends can be a tremendous boon to your practice, you can still make headway
on your own:
" Observe the precepts. Moral conduct -- codified in Buddhism
as the five precepts -- is the absolute bedrock of spiritual progress. Get to
know the five precepts well and make an effort to follow them. Learn which ones
are most difficult for you to keep and what situations put you in danger of breaking
them. Make adjustments in your behavior accordingly. When you break a precept,
just pick yourself up, reflect on why you fell short, and make the determination
not to let it happen again. Challenge yourself with the precepts, but be patient:
perfecting one's morality is a lifelong practice. (See also: "The Healing
Power of the Precepts".)
" Choose your company with care. The Buddha
pointed out that we tend to pick up the qualities -- both good and bad -- of the
people with whom we associate (see Iti 76). If we care about developing good qualities
in ourselves, it's therefore imperative that we associate as much as possible
with good people and stay away from those who have little respect for the the
precepts and wisdom. But remember that Buddhists don't have a monopoly on goodness
of character; you'll find plenty of people from all walks of life who have admirable
attributes such as generosity, patience, kindness, truthfulness, and so on. Get
to know these people and see what you can learn from them about developing goodness
in yourself.
" Read, read, read.Nowadays there are countless books and
pamphlets on Buddhism, transcribed Dhamma talks, translated suttas, etc., available
both in print and on the Internet. Some of them are wonderful, some are rubbish;
developing the discernment to distinguish one from the other is itself a crucial
aspect of learning Dhamma. The Buddha's own test of authenticity is invaluable
in sorting the wheat from the chaff (see AN VIII.53 and the Study Guide "Recognizing
the Dhamma"). Here are some good starting points:
o The suttas. For some
suggestions about how to read them -- and which ones to read -- see the article
"Befriending the Suttas".
o Study Guides. These anthologies of readings
from the suttas are designed as aids for individual or group study on particular
topics.
o "Getting Started: Suggested Points of Entry to this Website"
o What are some good beginning books on Buddhism? (Frequently Asked Question).
" Take a class. If at all possible, take part in an introductory meditation
workshop or retreat conducted by an experienced teacher. Even if you have to travel
a long distance in order to attend, you may be rewarded with enough helpful advice
to nourish your meditation and your studies for a long time to come.
Even
if you don't have a community of friends, you can still learn to ask yourself
good questions -- questions that will propel you deeper in your understanding
of Dhamma (see "Questions of Skill"). Who was the Buddha? What did he
accomplish? What is the goal of Buddhist practice? What is enlightenment? Why
is morality the foundation of the Buddha's teachings? What is the purpose of meditation?
What is wisdom? Am I honestly following the path that the Buddha laid out? What
is the role of faith? If you can keep questions like these alive in your heart,
you're bound to stay on track.
I
want to become a Buddhist. How do I do that?
It begins with one deceptively
simple act: making the inner commitment to "take refuge" in the Triple
Gem, to accept the Buddha, Dhamma, and Sangha as your source of spiritual guidance.[1]
This act is what makes one nominally "Buddhist". But going for refuge
also implies a willingness -- if only provisional, at first -- to accept the cornerstone
of the Buddha's teachings: the law of kamma. According to this universal principle,
if you act unskillfully and make poor ethical choices, you are bound to suffer
the consequences; if you choose wisely and act in line with the noblest ideals,
you stand to benefit accordingly.[2] In other words, your happiness ultimately
depends on the quality of your choices and actions; you alone are responsible
for your happiness. Your first act after seeking refuge should therefore be to
resolve to observe the five precepts -- the five basic principles of living that
can help prevent you from making grossly unskillful choices. This is where the
practice of Buddhism begins.
You don't need a formal public ceremony or "initiation"
to make any of this official. There are no equivalents in Buddhism to Christianity's
"baptism" or "confirmation" rituals. You don't have to dress
differently or wear a badge that says, "I am now a Buddhist." The practice
of the Dhamma is a private matter and no one needs to know about it but you. Many
Buddhists do, however, find it invaluable to renew their commitment to the Triple
Gem and to the precepts from time to time in a more formal way, enlisting the
help of a good friend, a respected meditation teacher, or a member of the monastic
community (Sangha) as a witness.[3] Administering the refuges and precepts to
laypeople is a duty that Buddhist monks are glad to perform.
Many people find
it difficult to sustain their commitment to the Dhamma on their own, without the
support of like-minded friends and companions. (It can be hard to stick to the
precepts if you're surrounded by people who see no harm in telling lies, or in
having a secret romantic affair now and then, or in going out drinking all night.)
You may have to do a little patient detective work to find this kind of support
(see How can I find other people with whom to study Dhamma and practice meditation?,
above).
Having taken these first steps, you can proceed along the Buddhist
path in your own way and at your own pace. Although you can learn a great deal
about Dhamma on your own, your understanding will grow by leaps and bounds once
you find a good teacher -- someone whom you trust and respect, who keeps to the
precepts, and who understands the Dhamma and can communicate it clearly.[4] Other
aids to progress in understanding the Dhamma are these: deepening your understanding
of the precepts; studying the suttas;[5] getting to know monks or nuns (the Sangha)
and becoming acquainted with their traditions; developing a keen, discerning ear
that can recognize which of today's popular spiritual teachings actually ring
true to what the Buddha taught;[6] and learning meditation. How you proceed is
entirely up to you, but the bottom line is this: learn what the Buddha taught
and put it into practice in your life as best you can.
If you ever decide
that the Buddha's teachings aren't for you, you are free to walk away at any time
and find your own way. There is no ceremony for renouncing the Buddha's teachings.
Just remember: your happiness is in your own hands.
Notes:
1. See Refuge:
An Introduction to the Buddha, Dhamma, and Sangha by Thanissaro Bhikkhu.
2.
See the opening verses of the Dhammapada.
3. For the standard Pali formula
for requesting the refuges and precepts, see A Chanting Guide: Pali Passages with
Translations. [Go back]
4. See "Admirable friendship (kalyanamittata)"
in the Path to Freedom pages.
5. See "Befriending the Suttas: Some Suggestions
for Reading the Pali Discourses".
6. See the Study Guide "Recognizing
the Dhamma," prepared by Thanissaro Bhikkhu.
I'd
like to have a Buddhist wedding. Any suggestions?
In the world of Theravada
Buddhism marriage is regarded as a civil contract, not as a spiritual or religious
union. Thus there is no standard Buddhist liturgy for marriage. You may simply
include whatever texts or passages you and your spouse-to-be find inspiring.
A
wedding is an excellent time to renew one's commitment both to the Triple Gem
and to living in accordance with the five precepts. In Buddhist countries a couple
might pay a visit to the local monastery shortly before or after their wedding
to offer food to the monastic community, recite the refuges and precepts in a
formal way, receive a little Dhamma instruction, and possibly receive a blessing
or two from the monks. If such a visit isn't possible for you, you might put together
your own refuges and precepts ceremony (use the formal ceremony as a guide). You
might also consider reciting the "Five Subjects for Frequent Recollection,"
the Maha-mangala Sutta, or any other passages that inspire you.
See also:
" In the Subject Index, look up "Lay Buddhist practice" and
"Marriage"
" A Chanting Guide: Pali Passages with English Translations
What were the Buddha's views on
divorce?
In Theravada Buddhism divorce (like marriage) is regarded as a civil
matter, rather than a religious or spiritual one. I don't know of any suttas in
which the Buddha expresses an opinion about divorce. The Buddha did, however,
have some suggestions about how a couple should behave while they are married
(see DN 31).
For some observations on how divorce is understood in Sri Lanka,
see The Position of Women in Buddhism, by Dr. (Mrs.) L.S. Dewaraja.
What
were the Buddha's views on homosexuality?
From what I've read in the suttas,
the Buddha gave no indication that one's sexual orientation has any bearing on
one's spiritual practice. The five precepts, which form the most basic foundation
of a moral life in Buddhism, encourage the abstention from "sexual misconduct",
a term that generally refers to sexual activity between two people outside of
a long-term committed relationship. It has nothing to do with "orientation".
The Buddha did, however, have strong words to say about sexuality/sensuality
in general, since it is one of the most powerful expressions of human craving
and attachment. And craving -- the second Noble Truth -- is a root cause of human
suffering. The Buddha was very clear: if you're genuinely concerned about your
long-term happiness, then it's worth reassessing the value of engaging in activities
-- be they heterosexual, homosexual, or non-sexual -- that feed your cravings:
Even if it's with pain,
you should abandon
sensual desires
if you
aspire
to future safety from bondage.
Alert,
with a mind well-released,
touch
release now here,
now there.
An attainer-of-wisdom,
having fulfilled
the holy life,
is said to have gone
to the end of the world, gone
beyond.
[Iti 101]
It is worth noting that the Buddha explicitly discouraged his followers
-- men and women, alike -- from dwelling on their sexual identity (AN VII.48).
Although in this particular sutta he was describing heterosexuals, the message
clearly applies to everyone.
What
were the Buddha's views on abortion?
Practicing Buddhists observe the five
precepts as a foundation for the moral life that spiritual progress requires.
The first of these precepts is to "refrain from destroying living creatures".
Since Theravada Buddhism regards human life as beginning at the moment of conception,[1]
killing a fetus implies killing a human being, making abortion patently incompatible
with the first precept.
One indication of the seriousness with which the Buddha
regarded abortion is found in the Vinaya, the collection of texts that define
the conduct and duties of Buddhist monastics. According to the Vinaya, if a bhikkhu
or bhikkhuni should facilitate an abortion, or if a woman should get an abortion
based on their recommendation, then that bhikkhu or bhikkhuni is immediately expelled
from the Sangha, having broken one of the four cardinal rules of monastic conduct.[2]
Notes:
1. According to the Pali texts, conception occurs when three things
are simultaneously present: the mother (i.e., a fertile egg), the father (a sperm
cell), and the gandhabba (the kammic energy of the being that is seeking rebirth).
If all three successfully coincide, human consciousness arises in the fertilized
ovum and rebirth occurs. For a description of this process, see the Mahatanhasankhaya
Sutta (MN 38). See Bhikkhu Bodhi's translation of this sutta (along with helpful
footnotes) in "The Middle Length Discourse of the Buddha" (Boston: Wisdom
Publications, 1995).
2. This rule (Parajika #3), which applies equally to
bhikkhunis as well as bhikkhus, states:
Should any bhikkhu [or bhikkhuni]
intentionally deprive a human being of life, or search for an assassin for him,
or praise the advantages of death, or incite him to die (thus): "My good
man, what use is this wretched, miserable life to you? Death would be better for
you than life," or with such an idea in mind, such a purpose in mind, should
in various ways praise the advantages of death or incite him to die, he [she]
also is defeated and no longer in communion.
The word-commentary to this rule
makes clear that abortion counts as "intentionally depriving a human being
of life". See The Buddhist Monastic Code, Vol. I
How
should I teach Buddhism to my children?
The Buddha's advice to parents is
straightforward: help your children become generous, virtuous, responsible, skilled,
and self-sufficient adults [see DN 31 and Sn II.4]. Teaching Buddhism to one's
children does not mean giving them long lectures about dependent co-arising, or
forcing them to memorize the Buddha's lists of the eightfold this, the ten such-and-suches,
the seventeen so-and-sos. It simply means giving them the basic skills they'll
need in order to find true happiness. The rest will take care of itself.
The
single most important lesson parents can convey to their children is that every
action has consequences. Each moment presents us with an opportunity, and it is
up to us to choose how we want to think, speak, or act. It is these choices that
eventually determine our happiness. This is the essence of kamma, the basic law
of cause and effect that underlies the Dhamma. It also happens to be the message
behind one of the few recorded teachings the Buddha gave to his only child, Rahula.[1]
This sutta -- the Ambalatthikarahulovada Sutta (MN 61) -- offers parents some
important clues about teaching Dhamma to young children -- in terms of both the
content of what to teach and the method to use.
In this sutta the Buddha reprimands
the seven year old Rahula for telling a small lie. The content of the Buddha's
lesson here is clear and simple: it concerns right speech, and helping Rahula
keep himself true to the fundamental principles of virtue. There are several noteworthy
aspects to the Buddha's method. First, by artfully drawing comparisons to an everyday
utensil (in this case, a water dipper), the Buddha makes his point in vivid and
age-appropriate language that Rahula can easily understand. Second, the Buddha
doesn't launch into a long-winded abstract lecture on the nature of kamma, but
instead keeps the lesson focused on the immediate issue at hand: choosing your
actions carefully. Third, although the five precepts do indeed constitute the
fundamental framework for moral conduct, the Buddha does not mention them here
-- presumably because some of the precepts (concerning sexuality and using intoxicants)
are simply not relevant to most seven year olds. (Perhaps the Buddha had more
to say about the precepts by the time Rahula was a teenager.) Fourth, the Buddha
keeps Rahula engaged during the lesson by asking him simple questions; this is
no dry, soporific lecture. And finally, the Buddha takes advantage of the opportunity
presented by this "teaching moment" to expand into deeper territory,
to explain to Rahula the importance of reflecting inwardly before, during, and
after performing an action of any sort -- whether of body, speech, or mind. The
Buddha thus places Rahula's original small misdeed into a much broader context,
transforming it into a lesson of deep and lasting significance.
Although most
of us who are parents can only dream of teaching our children as consciously and
effectively as the Buddha did, we can still learn from his example. But before
we can translate his example into action, there is one crucial point to recognize:
the Buddha's instructions to his son were given by someone who really knew what
he was talking about; Rahula's teacher was someone who truly practiced what he
preached, a role model par excellence. So the message is clear: if we hope to
instruct our children about matters concerning the path of Dhamma, we had better
be sure that we ourselves are practicing on that path. If you extol the virtues
of skillful qualities such as generosity, truthfulness, and patience, but your
children only see you being stingy, overhear you telling lies, or see you losing
your temper, then your message will be lost. Of course, you need not have perfected
the Dhamma in order to instruct your children, but for your instruction to carry
any weight your children must be able to witness firsthand that you are earnestly
striving to put these same teachings into practice yourself. And if you can inspire
them by your example and give them the skills they need to know to live in tune
with the Dhamma, then you've given them a rare gift indeed:
The wise hope
for a child
of heightened or similar birth,
not for one
of lowered birth,
a disgrace to the family.
These children in the world,
lay followers,
consummate
in virtue, conviction;
generous, free from stinginess,
shine forth in any
gathering
like the moon
when freed from a cloud. [Iti 74]
If you're
looking for books to read to (or with) a younger child, I recommend the series
of colorfully illustrated Jataka[2] story books and coloring books available from
Dharma Publishing. These books (in the "Jataka Tales Series") recount
stories of the Buddha's former lives and provide many opportunities for discussion
of basic moral principles with children. They are most appropriate for children
under 10.
Notes:
1. Seven years after leaving his home and family to begin
his spiritual quest, Siddhattha Gotama -- now the Buddha -- returned on the first
of several visits to his family to teach them Dhamma. The only suttas that record
the Buddha's instructions to his son Rahula are these: MN 61 (Rahula is 7 years
old), in which the Buddha explains the importance of self-reflection before, during,
and after performing any action; MN 62 (age 18), in which the Buddha teaches him
breath meditation; MN 147 (age 20, just after his ordination as a bhikkhu), in
which the Buddha queries him about impermanence, and Rahula thereby becomes an
arahant (this sutta is identical to SN XXXV.121); SN XXII.91 (= SN XVIII.21) and
SN XXII.92 (= SN XVIII.22), in which the Buddha answers his questions about uprooting
I-making and conceit; and Sn II.11, in which the Buddha praises to him the virtues
of the homeless life.
2. The Jataka, or "Birth Stories", is a book
in the Khuddaka Nikaya that recounts tales of the Buddha's former lives prior
to his final rebirth as Siddhattha Gotama. In previous lives he was born a human,
or a bird, or a monkey, etc.; in each life he dedicated himself to developing
and strengthening a wholesome quality of mind (parami). One Jataka story might
be about developing patience, the next about developing generosity, and so on.
Are Buddhists vegetarian?
Some
are, some aren't. I know of no evidence in the Pali Canon to suggest that the
Buddha discouraged his lay followers from eating meat. Although some people may
point to the first of the five precepts as evidence that the Buddha asked his
followers to be vegetarian, this precept only concerns the intentional act of
depriving a living being of life, and says nothing about consuming the flesh of
an animal that is already dead. Many Buddhists (and, of course, non-Buddhists)
do eventually lose their appetite for meat out of compassion for other living
creatures, but from the strict Theravada Buddhist perspective, the choice of whether
or not to eat meat is purely a matter of personal preference.
Theravada monks
are forbidden to eat certain kinds of meat,[1] but because their food is provided
by the generosity of lay supporters,[2] who may or may not themselves be vegetarian,[3]
they are not required to practice strict vegetarianism. Nor are Theravada monks
required to eat everything that is placed in their alms-bowl; a monk intent on
pursuing vegetarianism may therefore simply ignore the meat in his bowl. In parts
of Asia where vegetarianism is unheard of, however, vegetarian monks face a clear
choice: eat meat or starve.
Taking part in killing for food (hunting, fishing,
trapping, butchering, etc.) is definitely incompatible with the first precept,
and should be avoided.
But what if I eat -- or just purchase -- meat: aren't
I simply encouraging someone else to do the killing for me? How can letting someone
else do the "dirty work" possibly be consistent with the Buddhist principle
of non-harming, that cornerstone of Right Resolve? This is tricky. Although the
suttas are silent on this question, I personally believe it would be wrong to
order someone, "Please kill that chicken for me," since it incites that
person to break the first precept.[4] Surely this is unskillful kamma. (Consider
this whenever you're tempted to order, say, a fresh-killed lobster at a restaurant;
by placing your order you are, in fact, ordering its death.) But purchasing a
piece of dead animal meat is another matter. Although my purchase may indeed help
keep the butcher or restaurateur in business, I am not asking him to kill on my
behalf. Whether he kills another cow tomorrow is his choice, not mine. This is
a difficult but important point, one that reveals the fundamental distinction
between personal choices (choices aimed at altering my own behavior) and political
ones (those aimed at altering others' behavior). Each of us must discover for
ourselves where lies the boundary between the two. It is crucial to remember that
the Buddha's teachings are, first and foremost, tools to help us learn to make
good personal choices (kamma); they are not prescriptions for political action.
We could not survive long in this world without bringing harm of one sort
or another to other creatures. No matter how carefully we trod, countless insects,
mites, and other creatures inadvertently perish under our feet with every step.
Where, then, do we even begin to draw the line between "acceptable"
and "unacceptable" harm? The Buddha's answer was very clear and very
practical: the five precepts. He didn't ask his followers to become vegetarian;
he simply asked us to observe the precepts. For many of us, this is challenge
enough. This is where we begin.
Notes:
1. Theravada monks are forbidden
to eat the flesh of humans, elephants, horses, dogs, snakes, lions, tigers, leopards,
bears, hyenas, and panthers. A monk is also forbidden to eat raw fish or meat,
or any fish or meat that he sees, hears, or suspects was killed specifically for
him (see the description of "staple foods" in The Buddhist Monastic
Code). A monk who eats any of those kinds of meat commits an offense that he must
then confess to his fellow monks. These rules do not imply that a monk must not
eat meat -- only that a monk must be careful as to which kinds of meat he does
eat.
2. See "The Economy of Gifts" by Thanissaro Bhikkhu.
3.
Monastics within some schools of Mahayana Buddhism do practice vegetarianism.
See The Buddhist Religion: A Historical Introduction (fourth edition) by R.H.
Robinson & W.L. Johnson (Belmont, California: Wadsworth, 1997), pp. 213-14.
4. This is in keeping with the monks' rule about not eating meat that he sees,
hears, or suspects was killed specifically for him. See The Buddhist Monastic
Code
Are there any enlightened
people in the world nowadays?
How can I tell who's really enlightened?
I
wouldn't be a Buddhist if I didn't think enlightenment were possible. The Buddha
himself observed that as long there are people practicing correctly in line with
the noble eightfold path, there will continue to be enlightened beings in the
world (DN 16). Even better evidence of the reality of enlightenment lies in the
"gradual" nature of the Buddha's teachings. In the suttas, the Buddha
speaks again and again of the many rewards awaiting those who follow the Path,
long before they reach nibbana: the happiness that comes from developing generosity;
the happiness that comes from living according to principles of virtue; the happiness
that comes from developing loving-kindness (metta); the happiness that comes from
practicing meditation and discovering the exquisite bliss of a quiet mind; the
happiness that comes from abandoning painful states of mind; and so on. These
can be tasted for yourself, to varying degrees, through Dhamma practice. Once
you've personally verified a few of the Buddha's teachings, it becomes ever-easier
to accept the possibility that the rest of his teachings are plausible -- including
his extraordinary claim that enlightenment is accessible to us.
It's probably
best not to spend too much time speculating on someone else's degree of enlightenment,
simply because our own delusion and defilements are bound to cloud our vision.
Your time is far better spent looking inwards and asking yourself, "Am I
enlightened? Have I made an end of suffering and stress?" If the answer is
negative, then you have more work to do. Some lines of questioning are, however,
well worth pursuing in regard to someone else's purity -- especially when deciding
whether or not to accept that person as your Dhamma teacher: "Does this person
seem to be truly happy? Does he or she live by the precepts? Is the interpretation
of Dhamma that he or she teaches a valid one? Can I learn something of real value
from him or her?" It can take a long and close association with someone before
you can begin to answer these questions with any confidence (AN IV.192). But if
you do find someone possessing this rare constellation of good qualities, stay
with that person: he or she probably has something of lasting value to teach you.
Finally, one rule of thumb that I've found helpful: someone who goes around
claiming to be enlightened (or dropping hints to that effect) probably isn't --
at least not in the sense the Buddha had in mind.
See also: "Recognizing
the Dhamma" (Study Guide)
What
are some good beginning books on Buddhism?
" Buddhist Dictionary, by
Nyanatiloka Mahathera (Kandy: Buddhist Publication Society, 1980). A classic handbook
of important terms and concepts in Theravada Buddhism. A valuable reference for
newcomers and veterans, alike.
" The Buddhist Religion: A Historical
Introduction (fourth edition) by R.H. Robinson & W.L. Johnson (Belmont, California:
Wadsworth, 1997). An excellent college-level introductory text that traces the
evolution of all the main schools of Buddhism from their early beginnings to the
present day.
" Eight Mindful Steps to Happiness by Ven. Henepola Gunaratana
(Boston: Wisdom Publications, 2001). An excellent guide to bringing the eightfold
path into one's daily life.
" The Experience of Buddhism: Sources and
Interpretations (second edition) by John S. Strong (Belmont, California: Wadsworth,
2002). A very useful anthology of excerpts from key Buddhist texts representing
all the major schools of Buddhism. Although intended primarily as a companion
to Robinson & Johnson's The Buddhist Religion (see above), it stands well
on its own.
" Mindfulness in Plain English by Ven. Henepola Gunaratana
(Boston: Wisdom Publications, 1992). A clear and helpful introduction to the practice
of mindfulness meditation.
" Noble Strategy: Essays on the Buddhist Path
by Thanissaro Bhikkhu (1999; Available from Metta Forest Monastery, PO Box 1409,
Valley Center, CA 92082, USA). A fine collection of introductory essays, which
are also available individually here on the website.
" Refuge: An Introduction
to the Buddha, Dhamma, & Sangha by Thanissaro Bhikkhu (Geoffrey DeGraff) (1996;
Available from Metta Forest Monastery, PO Box 1409, Valley Center, CA 92082, USA).
A collection of short essays and readings from the Pali suttas that explain the
basic principles of living and practicing the path of Dhamma.
" What
the Buddha Taught by Walpola Rahula (New York: Grove Press, 1986). An overview
of the teachings of Theravada Buddhism, including chapters on each of the Four
Noble Truths, along with excerpts from selected suttas and the Dhammapada. For
several decades, a standard introductory text. Readily available at many bookstores.
" See also "Getting Started," which includes suggested readings
on beginning meditation practice.
Where
can I find a copy of the complete Pali Canon (Tipitaka)?
Print editions:
If
you're thinking of purchasing your own printed copy of the Tipitaka, be forewarned:
the Pali Canon is huge; owning a complete set is a serious commitment. The Pali
Text Society's edition of the Tipitaka (English translation) fills over 12,000
pages in approximately fifty hardbound volumes, taking up about five linear feet
of shelf space, and costing about US$2,000. Moreover, a few of the more obscure
books in the Tipitaka are simply unavailable in English translation, so if you
really must read the entire Tipitaka, you'll just have to learn Pali.
The
PTS has for over a century been the leading publisher of the Tipitaka, both in
romanized Pali and in English translation, but many of their translations are
now badly out of date. Much better translations of several portions of the Canon
are now available from other publishers. Here are my recommendations for printed
translations that add up to a useful -- if incomplete -- version of the Tipitaka:
" Vinaya Pitaka. The Book of the Discipline, I.B. Horner, trans. (Oxford:
Pali Text Society, 1993) [6 vols]. To study the many rules for bhikkhus and bhikkhunis
that are scattered throughout the Vinaya Pitaka, see Thanissaro Bhikkhu's The
Buddhist Monastic Code, Volume I: The Patimokkha Training Rules Translated and
Explained and The Buddhist Monastic Code, Volume II: The Khandhaka Training Rules
Translated and Explained
" Sutta Pitaka. An excellent anthology of selected
suttas and texts from the five Nikayas is Handful of Leaves, Thanissaro Bhikkhu,
trans. (Santa Cruz: Sati Center for Buddhist Studies, 2003) [4 vols.]. Translations
from specific portions of the Nikayas include the following:
o Digha Nikaya:
The Long Discourses of the Buddha (formerly titled Thus Have I Heard), Maurice
Walshe, trans. (Boston: Wisdom Publications, 1987) [1 vol.]
o Majjhima Nikaya:
The Middle Length Discourses of the Buddha, Bhikkhu Ñanamoli and Bhikkhu
Bodhi, trans. (Boston: Wisdom Publications, 1995) [1 vol.]
o Samyutta Nikaya:
The Connected Discourses of the Buddha, Bhikkhu Bodhi, trans. (Boston: Wisdom
Publications, 2000) [2 vols.]
o Anguttara Nikaya: The Book of Gradual Sayings,
F.L. Woodward and E.M. Hare, trans. (Oxford: Pali Text Society, 1994) [5 vols.]
An excellent anthology of about one-fifth the entire Anguttara Nikaya is Nyanaponika
Thera and Bhikkhu Bodhi's Numerical Discourses of the Buddha: An Anthology of
Suttas from the Anguttara Nikaya (Walnut Creek, CA: Altamira Press, 1999).
o
Khuddaka Nikaya (for a more detailed list, see the Khuddaka Nikaya page):
"
Khuddakapatha: Handful of Leaves (Vol. 4), Thanissaro Bhikkhu, trans. (Santa Cruz:
Sati Center for Buddhist Studies, 2003) [1 vol.]
" Dhammapada: Dhammapada:
A Translation, Thanissaro Bhikkhu, trans. (Barre, Massachusetts: Dhamma Dana Publications,
1997); The Dhammmapada: Pali Text and Translation with Stories in Brief and Notes,
prose translation by Narada Thera (Buddhist Missionary Society, 1978; available
from Pariyatti Books) [1 vol.]
" Udana: The Udana and the Itivuttaka,
John D. Ireland, trans. (Kandy: Buddhist Publication Society, 1998) [1 vol.]
"
Itivuttaka: Itivuttaka: This Was Said by the Buddha, Thanissaro Bhikkhu, trans.
(Barre, Massachusetts: Dhamma Dana Publications, 2001) [1 vol.] or Handful of
Leaves (Vol. 4), Thanissaro Bhikkhu, trans. (Santa Cruz: Sati Center for Buddhist
Studies, 2003) {1 vol.]
" Suttanipata: The Sutta-Nipata, H. Saddhatissa,
trans. (London: Curzon Press, 1985) [1 vol.]
" Theragatha, Therigatha:
Elders' Verses, prose translation by K.R. Norman (Oxford: Pali Text Society, 1992)
" Vimanavatthu, Petavatthu, Patisambhidamagga, Buddhavamsa, Cariyapitaka,
Nettippakarana, Petakopadesa, Milindapañha: translations, of varying quality,
are available from the PTS.
" Apadana, Niddesa: I'm unaware of any English
translations of these books.
" Abhidhamma Pitaka. The essence of Abhidhamma
philosophy is contained in the first and last of the Abhidhamma's seven books;
only rarely do scholars and students wade into the murky waters of the middle
five. So, begin with these two books:
o Dhammasangani: Buddhist Psychological
Ethics, Mrs. C.A.F. Rhys Davids, trans., 3rd ed. (Oxford: Pali Text Society, 1993)
[1 vol]
o Patthana: Conditional Relations, Ven. U Narada, trans. (Oxford:
Pali Text Society, 1993) [2 vols.]
These books are difficult reading; you'll
welcome the sober guidance of the Abhidhammattha Sangaha, a medieval commentary
by Acariya Anuruddha. By far the best translation of this work is A Comprehensive
Manual of Abhidhamma, translated and edited by Mahathera Narada and Bhikkhu Bodhi
(Kandy: Buddhist Publication Society, 1993). [1 vol.]
Electronic editions:
Several complete Pali-only versions of the Tipitaka (in roman and other scripts)
are available online and on CD-ROM. As far as I know, Access to Insight has the
largest online collection of English language Tipitaka texts.
Miscellaneous
What's the relationship between "dana" and "fundraising"?
They are entirely unrelated -- or at least they should be. Alas, in recent
years the notion of dana seems to have been co-opted by many Buddhist organizations
in the West as just another fundraising gimmick, designed to appeal to our better
nature. How many times have we read fundraising letters from Buddhist organizations
that open with the familiar preamble: "Dana, or generosity, is the ancient
tradition that has kept the Buddha's teachings alive for over 2,500 years..."?
How many times have we seen long "wish lists" in these letters detailing
exactly what material goods are needed? And how many times have we heard meditation
centers ask for "suggested donations" to pay for their teachings? To
my mind, these valiant efforts at drumming up material support for Buddhist causes
only dampen the true spirit of dana, that weightless, heartfelt, and spontaneous
upwelling of generous action that lies at the very root of the Buddha's teachings.
Giving of any kind is unquestionably good. The Buddha encourages us to give
generously whenever anyone asks for help [Dhp 224]. And even the smallest of gifts,
when offered with a generous heart, has tremendous value: "Even if a person
throws the rinsings of a bowl or a cup into a village pool or pond, thinking,
'May whatever animals live here feed on this,' that would be a source of merit"
[AN III.57]. But the actual rewards of giving depend strongly on the climate in
which the giving occurs. The giver and the recipient -- the donor and the organization
-- share an equal responsibility in fostering a climate that makes the most of
generosity. If both are serious about putting the Buddha's teachings into practice,
they would do well to consider the following points:
First, the benefits of
giving multiply in accordance with the purity of the giver's motives. A gift we
give half-heartedly yields modest rewards for all concerned, whereas a gift given
with genuine open-handedness, "not seeking [our] own profit, not with a mind
attached [to the reward]," is of far greater value [AN VII.49]. If we give
with an expectation of receiving something from the recipient in return -- membership
benefits, a certificate of appreciation, a book, a meditation course, etc. --
we shortchange ourselves, and dilute the power of our generosity. Buddhist organizations
should therefore be cautious about rewarding gifts with these sorts of perquisites.
Second, the Buddha does not encourage us to ask for gifts. In fact, he says
quite the opposite: he encourages us to make do with what little we already have
[AN IV.28]. This theme of contentment-with-little echoes throughout the Buddha's
teachings. To my mind, a fundraiser's long "wish list" of needed items
conveys a sense of dissatisfaction, and thus seems at odds with this message.
Donors most enjoy giving when they know that their gift -- no matter how humble
it may be -- is truly appreciated by the recipient. If I have only a small gift
to give, I wonder if it will be appreciated -- or even noticed -- by an organization
with ambitious fundraising goals or a long and expensive list of needs. An organization
can promote the Buddha's teachings most effectively, and inspire the greatest
confidence among its supporters, by keeping its needs modest and its requests
rare.
Third, the purity of the recipient also matters [SN III.24]. When we
give to virtuous people -- those who, at the very least, abide by the five precepts
-- we not only acknowledge their intention to develop virtue (sila), but we also
reinforce our own resolve. Giving to virtuous people is thus a powerful kammic
force whose benefits extend far beyond the moment of giving itself. Generosity
and virtue are deeply intertwined; when we learn to exercise our generous impulses
skillfully, and give where the gift reaps the greatest fruit, we make the most
of them both. Whether we are giver or recipient, we stand to benefit most from
generosity when we take virtue seriously.
Finally, an appeal to fledgling
Buddhist groups and organizations: please be very, very patient, and resist the
temptation to make your organization grow. The success of a Buddhist organization
should never be measured in conventional commercial terms: number of members,
number of downloads, number of courses taught, amount of money raised, etc. Its
success can only be measured by how well it embodies the Buddha's teachings. If
it does good work that is rooted firmly in the principles of virtue, people who
recognize virtue when they see it will inevitably take notice and be inspired
to lend a hand with unbounded generosity. Any organization that can do this much
passes on to others, in the most direct way possible, the priceless tradition
of generosity, which is the heart and soul of Dhamma -- the greatest gift of all
[Dhp 354].
See also:
" "The Economy of Gifts," by Thanissaro
Bhikkhu
" "Generosity" in the Path to Freedom pages.
"
What's wrong with selling Dhamma books?
What's
wrong with selling Dhamma books?
What's the big deal about giving them away
free of charge?
There's nothing inherently wrong with selling Dhamma books.
Indeed, many commercial publishers provide a valuable service by producing high-quality
Dhamma books that are easier to find in bookstores than their free, privately
printed cousins. But that accessibility comes at a steep price. A publisher that
lives by its bottom line is inevitably forced to make editorial choices based
on what will or will not sell books. The result of this pressure is often a book
that presents a watered-down version of Dhamma, a Dhamma that may sound joyous,
uplifting, and pleasing, but which lacks the cutting edge of truth. It is unlikely,
for example, that people would flock to the bookstore and empty their wallets
to read about the Buddha's crucial teachings on renunciation, the drawbacks of
sensuality, or the value of reflecting on the unattractiveness of the body. The
market for people willing to spend money on this kind of truth is, alas, unprofitably
small.
But there is another, deeper reason to think twice about selling Dhamma
books. Since the Buddha's time, the teachings have traditionally been given away
free of charge, passing freely from teacher to student, from friend to friend.
The teachings are regarded as priceless, and have been conveyed to us across the
centuries by an unbroken stream of generosity -- the very foundation of all the
Buddha's teachings. That tradition continues with the production of free Dhamma
books. From the author, the stream flows onwards through those who give their
time to editing, typesetting, and printing the book; through the donors who sponsor
the printing; and through those who take care of distribution and mailing. If
you are fortunate enough to receive a book borne on this stream of generosity,
you learn an important lesson of Dhamma long before you even open the cover. The
instant someone puts a price tag on a Dhamma book, you not only have to pay money
for it, but you get less in return: you get a book that is merely about Dhamma,
instead of one that is itself an example of Dhamma in action. Which one do you
think has greater value?
So keep this in mind the next time you find yourself
spending money in exchange for the Dhamma -- whether it is in the form of a book,
an audio tape, a CD-ROM, a Dhamma talk, a meditation class, a retreat. The old
adage still applies: caveat emptor -- Let the buyer beware.
See also: What's
the relationship between 'dana' and 'fundraising'?
Kamma
Forty Dharma Talk
Kamma
Study Guide
Body Contemplation
Meditations 40 Dharma Talks
Mindfulness
in plain English
Non Violence study guide
Conversation
Dharma lights the way
Loving and dying
Pure
and simple
Recognizing the Dhamma
The Four Noble Truths
The
Seven Factors of Enlightenment
The Ten Armies
of Mara
The Ten Perfections
Awareness Itself
Bodhinyana
Inner
Strength
Merit
Starting
Out Small
Stream Entry
The
Five Aggregates
The five mental hindrances
The Ten Recollections
To
the last breath
When
you know for yourselves
The
Path of Concentration and Mindfulness
The
practice of chanting in Buddhism
The seven
part cause and effect
Three Vehicles
To comprehend suffering
Turning
the mind toward the Dharma
Two Kinds
of Bodhichitta
Using meditation to deal
with ...
The Bodhisattva Way of Life
The Psychedelic Experience
FAQs
Cleansing
the heart
The
affirming the Truths of the heart
The road to
Nirvana
A brief overview of Buddhist philosophy
Balancing Buddha Dhamma with family life
Buddhist philosophy
Great
Personalities
Meditation
The
practice of chanting in Buddhism
A
handbook for the relief of suffering
A
verb for Nirvana
Buddhists and Scientists
Discuss Neuroplasticity in Dharamsala
Jhana
not by the number
Looking inward
Meditation as medicine
Polishing the mind
Reading the mind
Straightening
out your view
The food of kindness
The meaning of taking refuge
The
roots of Buddhist romanticism
A
Buddhist Perspective on Vegetarianism
A
note on liberal Buddhism
Spiritual Healing
as the Energy Side of Einstein's Equation
Buddhism
and Nonviolence
The value of sadness
What mind is
Buddhist
psychotherapy as skillful means
Basic
Buddhism
Sentient
beings and Dukkha in Mahayana Buddhism
The
Heart Sutra
The Refuge
To
lead is to serve
The
Diamond Sutra
The
Sutra on Measuring and Reflecting
East Asian
Buddhist Studies
About Buddhism
How
to be a Buddhist? How does one start?
Non
Religion Buddhist Philosophy
Questions about
Buddhism
Religious Experience and the Parietal
Lobe of the Brain
A
Public Talk by Thich Nhat Hanh
Student-teacher
relationship
Autobiography of Phra Ajaan
Lee
The monk's rules
Training
the Attention and Exploring consciousness in Tibetan Buddhism
What
is Buddhism?
Questions about Buddhism
What Is The
Oneness of Life
A
Buddhist Approach to Dreams
The Autobiography
of a Forest Monk
The Buddhist Concept of
Impermanence
The Five Spiritual Powers
Spirituality, Religious Wisdom, and the Care
of the Patient
Buddhism: a modern perspective
A Brief History
of Eastern Ideas
A
Guide to Midfulness of Breathing and Tranquil Wisdom Meditation
The
Smaller Buddhist Catechism
The Manual of Light
An Awakened Vision
Ancient
Indian Buddhism and Ahijsa
Beginnings
and Endings
The Gospel of Buddha
The
Words of Buddha
Buddhism : a general outline
Buddhism
- A Scientific Experimental Path
Buddhist
Literature
History of Pure Land Buddhism
Foundation
of Buddhism
Historical
overview of the early Buddhist Councils
Introduction
to Agama Sutra
Introduction to the
Anapanasati Sutta
The Manual of the Constituents
of the Noble Path
Mahayana Buddhism
and Twenty-first Century Civilization
My
Political Thought on the life of the Buddha
Nothing
to surpass Buddhism
Peace and Human Security
Quotes on Buddhism
Rebirth
Renewal of Thai Buddhist belief in Kamma and Rebirth
The Manual of Right Views
The
Buddhist Conception of an Ecological Self
The
Manual of the Four Noble Truths
The
First Precept and its Environmental Significance
The
Manual of Cosmic Order
The
Buddhist Philosophy of Relations
The Power
of Chanting
The
stages of the Path
The
Soul-Theory in Buddhism
The manual of insight
Vibrating within
The
Dhammapada
Vijnaptimatrata and the Abhidharma
context of early Yogacara
Zen meditation
A Belief in the Oneness of Man
A
defense of Yogacara Buddhism
Buddhism
and Science
Buddhism and Suicide
Esoteric Buddhism
In
the presence of Nibbana
Kamma : The creative
life-force of human beings
The Bodhisattva
Ideal In Theravada
The Buddha and His Way
The Concept of Personality Revealed Through The Pancanikaya
The Dhammapada
The
King of the Devas as Student of the Buddha
The
Light of Asia
Theravada Buddhism
Women in Chan Buddhism
A
study in karma
Ancient
Buddhist Wisdom in the Light of Quantum Reality
Buddhism
And Mysticism
Buddhism
and Yoga
Buddhism - Getting started
Buddhism in America
Buddhist
Monasticism
Buddhist Philosophy and
Its European Parallels
Conceptions of the
Absolute in Mahayana Buddhism and Shinran
Consciousness
Timeline
The structure of Buddhist meditation
in the Paali suttas
A Commentary on the Oghatarana
Sutta
Early
Buddhism
Faith
in Buddhism
Karma Yoga
On
the Mysteries of Reincarnation
Heart
Sutra
Tara:
Her Origins and Development
The Diamond
Sutra
Yoga: The Law of Karma
You
will come back
Buddhist
Steps to an Ecology of Mind
Fa-Hsien:
A Record of Buddhistic Kingdoms
What is the
Mind?
A Buddhist view of Addiction
Are Buddhism and Unitarian Universalism Made
For Each Other?
Avalokitesvara's Appeal
Buddha
and Buddhism
Buddhism
Buddhism and Nonviolent Social Action
Buddhism and slavery
Buddhism
as a way of life
Buddhist principles for
human dignity
Buddhist Studies and its
Impact on Buddhism in Western Societies
Buddhist
views on karma
Definition of Buddhism
Dhammapada : Path of Truth
Four
Ways of Practising the Buddha-Dhamma
Reflections
on Western interest in Buddhism
A
Discourse on Malukyaputta Sutta
The
Doctrine of Dependent Origination
A Lamp for the
Enlightenment Path