Insight and Compassion:
Buddhist View of the September 11 Terrorist Attacks
Transcribed from a Dharma
Talk given by Rev. Patti Nakai, September 16, 2001 at BTC
this week I was planning to talk today about the six paramitas (Sanskrit: virtuous
practices), the usual topic for the O-higan (Japanese: equinox observance) service.
However, because of what happened on Tuesday, I realized this cannot be just another
O-higan talk. I need to, and we all need to, talk about what happened and how
we can look to the Buddha-Dharma to help us deal with our thoughts and feelings
about such a violent tragedy.
On Wednesday at the temple right before our
weekly study class got started, I received a call from a Mr. Ali of the Council
of Islamic Organizations asking for a Buddhist representative for the inter-faith
vigil they were sponsoring downtown at the Buckingham Fountain the next evening.
I gave him some names and numbers to call, but said if he really couldn't find
anyone, I could do it. When I called Mr. Ali back the next morning, he said that
with the short notice, people already had other plans. So I agreed to be the representative
since I felt it was important for the Buddhists to show their support for those
of Islamic faith who were being targeted as scapegoats. (Just the night before,
the police had to break up a crowd threatening to attack a mosque in Bridgeview.)
When I arrived I was glad I came, not just as a representative of the Buddhist
community, but also to stand as an Asian American among the non-Muslim clergy
who were all Caucasians.
Then much to the surprise of the vigil organizers,
the Rev. Jesse Jackson and some Rainbow Coalition members showed up and so did
people from the news media. Rev. Jackson gave an eloquent and moving speech. He
spoke out against scapegoating, citing the terrible tragedies of the Nazi persecution
of the Jews and the incarceration of Japanese Americans after the Pearl Harbor
attack. Following Rev. Jackson, there were speeches by the dozen clergymen and
women--two of the Jewish faith, two Muslims and the rest were Christian.
of the Christian ministers led the audience in prayer, but when it was my turn
near the end (the media people had long departed along with Rev. Jackson), I led
a brief meditation and gave a reading and comments on a passage from the Dhammapada,
the earliest collection of Shakyamuni Buddha's sayings. I would like to elaborate
on some of what I said because, as many of you have already felt this past week,
there is an outlook in Buddhism that puts us out of step with most of our country's
spokesmen and politicians.
In leading the meditation, I asked the gathering
not only to include the victims and their loved ones in their thoughts, but to
also remember that the hijackers also died in the jet crashes and they all had
parents, brothers, sisters and friends who are now in mourning. In his awakening
to the oneness of all life, Shakyamuni Buddha could no longer allow himself to
think of any living creature as less deserving of life than himself or anyone
else. Each life is precious and unique in the eyes of a Buddha. In his talks,
Shakyamuni uses phrases like "Buddha's child" to describe the bond he
feels towards each living being. So, each of the hijackers and their collaborators
is a child of Buddha. We have no right to talk about them as non-human creatures,
lower than insects. In flesh and blood, heart and mind, they were no different
from any of us.
Of course, this is not to condone the awful killing and destruction
they brought about. But we should realize these acts just didn't occur because
those people were suddenly possessed by the devil or some mysterious force. One
of the Muslim speakers pointed out the conditions which produce terrorists--the
economic and political oppression of whole societies of people who feel they are
the victims of the rich, powerful countries awash in luxuries. In the Buddhist
teachings, there is the basic principle called "dependent origination"--or
simply, the "law of karma." Each thing that happens in this world becomes
a cause and condition for other things to happen. We recite this law all the time
in the "Golden Chain" [recited at every Sunday service], that what I
think, say and do now will lead to the misery or happiness of myself and others
in the future. Although violent acts occur due to the causes and conditions of
the past, the law of karma points out the potential in each of us, from this moment
on, to think, say and do things that can lessen the violence in the world.
way to get started on the path of peace is to learn from Shakyamuni Buddha. Shakyamuni
had looked deep into himself and saw the seeds of violence in his own mind. In
the Dhammapada, we can hear the insights coming from his thorough self-examination.
The passage I read at Thursday's vigil was from the first chapter of the Dhammapada:
insulted me, hit me, beat me, robbed me,"
for those who brood on this,
hostility isn't stilled.
me, hit me, beat me, robbed me,"
for those who don't brood on this, hostility
Hostilities aren't stilled
through hostility, regardless.
Hostilities are stilled through non-hostility:
an unending truth.
who don't realize
That we're here on the verge of perishing,
Those who do:
their quarrels are stilled.
--Translated by Thanissaro Bhikkhu (monk name of
Available at www.accesstoinsight.org/canon/khuddaka/dhp/1.html
I then explained that the early English translations of the passage used the
phrasing "Hate is overcome by love" (as in our temple's service book).
Maybe in the Victorian age it was considered awkward to write "hostility"
and "non-hostility" in the same sentence. But I feel that early attempt
at translation misses an important point. "We can be full of love,"
I said at the vigil, "Love for our friends and family, love of our country--but
if there is one tiny seed of hostility in us, all that love cannot overcome the
hate." In the original Pali language text, Shakyamuni clearly states that
hostility (verena) is ended only by non-hostility (a-verena). He is not glibly
preaching, "Love thy neighbor," but is confessing his struggle to confront
the hate in himself.
What this Dhammapada passage illustrates is the paramita
of kshanti. Called nin-niku in Japanese, it means (nin = shinobu ) to bear, endure
(niku = joku) abuse and insult. Although kshanti is commonly translated as "patience,"
many Buddhist texts use the word "insight." This is because when you
have the insight to realize that abuse and injury are brought about by myriad
causes and conditions, you no longer take it personally and there is no reason
to hate anyone for the way they treat you. This is what kshanti really is, not
an easy paramita to practice, but one for us to keep in mind now more than ever.
For us to talk about "Oneness" at our temple, we must acknowledge
that the four jet crashes--at the two towers of the World Trade Center, at the
Pentagon and into the ground in rural Pennsylvania--are all part of one bright,
shining reality, the world of enlightenment, the Pure Land. Terrorism is not just
something way over there that suddenly came to inflict misery on our country.
In the minds of each of us is the same hostility that drove the hijackers to their
desperate actions. Just as the Rev. Billy Graham and other Christian ministers
say this is the time to turn to God, for Buddhists, this is the time to listen
earnestly to the Dharma--to become aware of the working of karma in all events
and to cultivate a sense of fellowship with all living beings. This is the time
to learn the real meanings of the words "insight" and "compassion."
© 2001 by Patti Nakai.
contact the author for permission to reproduce part or all of this article.